UNIVERSITY OF VAASA Faculty of Philosophy ICS-Programme Marie Eyongakpa Youth Participation in religious activities: Case study of the Congregations of Mikael Agricola and Munkkiniemi Churches in Helsinki, Finland and the Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe, Cameroon A Comparative Perspective Master’s thesis Vaasa 2012 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................. 4 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT............................................................................................. 6 1. INTRODUCTION................................................................................................. 7 1.1 Aim of study and research question ..................................................................... 9 1.2 Research method ............................................................................................... 12 2 .THEORETICAL FRAMEWORKS AND METHODOLOGY ................................. 14 2.1 Theoretical framework. ..................................................................................... 14 2.2 Methodology ..................................................................................................... 17 2.2.1 Comparative method ................................................................................... 17 2.2.2 Qualitative method ..................................................................................... 19 3. THE STRUCTURE OF FINNISH EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH IN MIKAEL AGRICOLA AND MUNKKINIEMI CONGREGATIONS IN HELSINKI, FINLAND .................................................................................................................. 22 3.1 The structure of Evangelical Lutheran Church ................................................... 22 3.1.1 The policy of the Church ............................................................................ 26 3.1.2 The confirmation training ........................................................................... 27 3.2 The structure of Mikael Agricola parish............................................................. 29 3.2.1 Role of Mikael Agricola parish ................................................................... 29 3.2.2 Youths participation in Mikael Agricola Church ......................................... 30 3.2.3 Church policy towards youth work at Mikael Agricola congregation .......... 31 3.2.4 Factors influencing youth participation in Mikael Agricola Church............. 33 3.2.5 Vision of youth work in Agricola Church ................................................... 34 3.2.6 Challenges faced by youths in Mikael Agricola Church .............................. 35 3.3 Recommendations for youth work in Agricola ................................................... 35 3.4 The structure of Munkkiniemi Church ............................................................... 36 2 3.4.1 The role of Munkkiniemi in youth work ..................................................... 38 3.4.2 Youths participation in Munkkiniemi Church ............................................. 38 3.4.3 Church policy towards youth work at Munkkiniemi congregation ............... 39 3.4.4 Vision of youth work in Munkkiniemi congregation ................................... 40 3.4.5 Factors influencing youth’s participation in Munkkiniemi congregation. .... 41 3.5 Recommendations for youth work in Munkkiniemi ........................................... 42 4. THE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH, CAMEROON ................................................. 44 4.1 Presbyterian Church policy towards youth work ................................................ 48 4.1.1. Confirmation training ................................................................................ 50 4.2 The Christian Youth Fellowship (C.Y.F) of Presbyterian Church ...................... 51 4.2.1 The structure of Christian youth fellowship movement ............................... 56 4.3 The history of Limbe, Cameroon. ...................................................................... 58 4.4 The role of Down Beach Limbe Congregation ................................................... 60 4.3.1 The Church policy towards youth works in Down Beach Limbe. ................ 61 4.3.2 Youths participation in Down Beach Limbe, Cameroon. ............................. 62 4.3.3 Factors influencing youths participation in Down Beach Limbe, Cameroon 64 4.3.4 Youths vision in Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe, Cameroon ....... 65 4.3.5 Challenges faced by youths at Down Beach Limbe, Cameroon ................... 65 4.5 Recommendations for youth work in Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe, Cameroon. .............................................................................................................. 66 5. COMPARATIVE STUDY OF YOUTH’S PARTICIPATION IN MIKAEL AGRICOLA, MUNKKINIEME PARISHES AND THE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH DOWN BEACH LIMBE, CAMEROON..................................................................... 68 5.1 Some common aspects among the three congregations ...................................... 69 5.2 Differences between the three Congregations .................................................... 71 6. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION ............................................................................ 78 6.1 The structure and policies in the three congregations. ........................................ 78 3 6.2 The cultural effect and consequences of youth’s attitude toward the church in the three congregations ................................................................................................. 84 6.3 Youths vision in the future in the three congregations. ....................................... 87 6. 4 Conclusion ....................................................................................................... 87 WORK CITED. .......................................................................................................... 89 APPENDICES ............................................................................................................ 92 Interviews with the youths in the three congregations .............................................. 92 4 UNIVERSITY OF VAASA Faculty of Philosophy: Discipline: ICS Author: Marie Eyongakpa Master’s Thesis: Youth par t ic ipat ion in relig ious act ivit ies: Case study o f the Mikae l Agr ico la and Munkkin iemi Churches in Helsinki, Finland and Presbyter ian Church Down Beach Limbe, Cameroon. A co mparat ive perspect ive. Degree: Master of Arts Date: 2012 Supervisor: Prof Christoph Parry ABSTRACT This study explores the inf luence o f culture on youth par t ic ipat ion in three co ngregat ions; Mikael Agr ico la and Munkkiniemi in t he Evangelical Lutheran Church, Finland and the Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe, Cameroon. The study hypothesized that youth in Mikael Agr ico la and Munkkiniemi congregat ions’ par t icipat ion in t he Church is pr imarily for socialisat ion reasons while sp ir itual concept is secondary whereas, the reverse is see n in Presbyter ian Church Down Beach Limbe, Cameroon. The methodo logy o f the study was based on Charles. C.Ragins comparat ive case study method with qualitat ive perspect ive, with the use of a designed interview template to gather empir ical data, and result s analysed. Case study methods were used to denote the similar it ies and differences in the three congregat ions through their structure, polic ies and youth act ivit ies. The two main challenges were, get t ing data and mater ials fro m Cameroon and Finnish language barr ier but I resor ted to group int erviews which were resourceful. The study explores the factors influencing youth at t itudes towards the Church, impact of Church po licies and it s implementat ion towards youth work, evaluat ing the degree o f youth work through their act ive part icipat ion in Church and recommendat ions for future youth work fro m youths, youth coordinators, pastors and some church author it ies. The study result acknowledges three factors influencing youth’s part icipat ion in the Church, the Church structure, policy and it s implementat ion and culture. KEYWORDS: Church, Youths, Part icipation, Mikael Agricola, Munkkiniemi, Presbyter ian Church Down Beach Limbe, Culture and Spir itual. 5 6 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I would like to thank God almighty for his guidance during my study period in Vaasa. Thanks to the entire staffs of the faculty of Philosophy in Vaasa. Special thanks go to all my respondents for accepting my interview invitations especially Rev. Miki Hans Abbia for feeding me with materials from Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe, Rev. Dr Raine Haikarainen, Saarinen Hertta, Lehto Mika, Anju lahtinen, Rev. Francis Ekola and Rev. Daniel Ayuk. Finally, I would like to extent my heartfelt gratitude to my entire family for their moral support especially Vivian Eyongakpa for undertaking the interview in Cameroon, Tarhyang Tabe, Jarkko Ylimäki for his continuous moral and financial support during my research period and Charis Ylimäki who inspired me to complete my study. 7 1. INTRODUCTION The Church is the community of God’s people brought together through the work of the Holy Spirit. It consist of all those who response to the call of Jesus Christ and acknowledges him as their lord and saviour. The church is the human institution that witness to right, justice, truth and peace in the social, economic and political life of the country in which it lives (Book of orders 1995: 3.) Religion has played a fundamental role in the lives of people in the community through politics and culture. People’s cultures do have a great deal to do with their religious life. Religion in the form of Pentecostalism, fundamentalism, charismatic movements and revivalism are flourishing in America, Africa and South East Asia, whereas in China and Vietnam, religion is under liberal government politics while Europe and North American with a large religious minorities are changing to a predominantly secular societies (Bryans 2010: 1). This research examines youth participation in religious activities in three congregations, Mikael Agricola and Munkkiniemi in Helsinki, Finland under the Evangelical Lutheran Church and the Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe, Cameroon. The first chapter covers an introduction with background information about the relationship between the Church and the state, the aim of the study, hypothesis, research question and research method. Chapter two covers the theoretical frame work and methodology of the study. Some cultural theories cited justifies why people behave differently as a result of cultural differences and the methodology entails a comparative study based on Charles C Ragins comparative research with the use of qualitative method through a designed interview template used in the three congregations. Chapter three focuses on the structure, policies on youth work, youth’s attitudes in the church, youth’s activities and their future vision of youth work in two congregations, Mikael Agricola and Munkkiniemi of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Finland. Chapter four covers the structure of Presbyterian Church, church policy, youth work, youth’s 8 attitudes in the church, youth’s activities and their future vision in Down Beach Limbe. Chapter five covers, the comparative perspective of the three congregations with emphasis on their similarities and differences. And the last chapter six covers result of the study and conclusion. Finland is a Nordic country formerly governed by the Swedish and Russians. Finland is also a bilingual country with two official languages, Finnish and Swedish. In Finland, the church and the state have carried out their duties in closed union. During the middle age the church in Finland was Roman Catholic and during reformation in the sixteenth century, the church changed to Lutheran. During the age of enlightenment, it was compulsory for all to belong to the church. The Russia era (1809-1917) where Finland was separated from Sweden, the church had a large degree of autonomy and was able to formed a decision making body of its own. When Finland had its independence in 1917, the church was an administrative independent entity and the church had the right to collect tax and in 1922, the freedom of religion act was passed where everyone had the right to confess their own faith (Antola et al 2006: 27-28). The cathedral of Helsinki is the main church in the Helsinki diocese made up of eighteen Finnish speaking parishes and three Swedish speaking parishes. Mikael Agricola church is a Finnish speaking parish in the Helsinki cathedral church organization (Helsinki tuomiokirkkoseurakunnan organisaatio) of the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland. The Helsinki (tuomiokkikkoseurakunnan) cathedral consists of five parishes Mikael Agricola, the castle church in Finland, St John’s parish, the old church and the chapel of Ruolahti (Kirkko Helsingissä.) Mikael Agricola and Munkkiniemi congregations in which this study is based, is in Helsinki which has been the capital of Finland for two hundred years in 2012. Helsinki is found in the South Eastern Finland. Finland is a welfare state whose economic success has influenced Finns culturally and spiritually. Munkkiniemi is a neighborhood in the West of Helsinki. Munkkiniemi is characterized by a high proportion of Swedish speaking population. Sub division within the regions 9 are Vanha Munkkineimi, Kuusisaari, Lehtisaari, Munkkivuori, Niemenmäki and Talinranta. Mikael Agricola is suited in the Southern Helsinki closed to the city centre. Cameroon is a country located in Central West Africa bordered to the West by Nigeria, to the North by Chad, to the East by Central Africa Republic and to the South by Equatorial Guinea, Gabon and Congo. Cameroon landscape is characterized with beaches, rain forest, savannah and mountain. Cameroon has a diversified ethnic group with different cultural views which has greatly influenced the people. The economic situation is bad due to poor management of funds and inequitable distribution of income resulting to high unemployment of many youths which has affected the living standard. This economic effect has greatly affected the spiritual and social life of young Cameroonians. The Church is an independent institute with no link to the state. Cameroonians have the right of freedom of worship. There are many denominations in Cameroon; Catholic, protestant, Baptist, and Pentecostal with none having greater influence over the others. Cameroons official languages are English and French. This study is based on the Christian youth movement of Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe. 1.1 Aim of study and research question The aim of the study is to understand if identity and cultural values have influence on youths´ participation in religious activities in these congregations. The target groups are youths and I am interested in factors influencing the spiritual growth of youths. Firstly, what motivated me to research on youth’s participation in these parishes was my personal experience in both countries. I have been a Christian youth fellowship member of the Presbyterian Church and have seen how youths are active in the church which was quite different in Finland after worshiping at the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Vantaa. I decided to carry out a comparative research in order to answer questions related to identity, cultural values, church policy and factors influencing young people attitude in the church. I initially wanted to conduct my research in the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Vantaa were I had worshiped and noticed that majority of the people were older people in the church and started wondering where are the youths? 10 After having an interview with the youth coordinator of Vantaa, I noticed the youths do have a “Friday café” which is more like a social evening and the confirmation camp meetings which were not frequent because of the poor turnover with a minimum number of youths being ten before a trip could be booked. It was difficult for me to meet the youths and get started, I finally decided to make enquires about Evangelical Lutheran congregation in Helsinki where I live and finally had contact with the Secretary of Helsinki diocese who directed me to the youths coordinator of Munkkiniemi congregation. After having an interview with the youth coordinator in Munkkiniemi who gave me an overview of youth work, I caught interest because I realized it was dominated by Swedish speaking Finns and had positive youth activities. And since my study was based on cultural impact on youth work I decided to undertake the study in Munkkiniemi. Since my target was the youth, I requested to undertake an interview with the youths and she promised to link me with some youths of eighteen and nineteen years. I had a group interview with the youths which confirmed the results of the interview I had with the youth coordinator and decided to move on. In the course of my research I came in contact with one of the assistant youth coordinator of Mikael Agricola, I made some enquires about youth work to be sure if it existed and she promised to have a word with the youth coordinator before giving me assurance for future interviews. Notwithstanding, I was invited to attend one of their Wednesday services where most youths can be contacted. I visited the Wednesday service which was quite amazing with a turnout of over 200 youths which gave me a close picture of my home congregation. I was indeed glad to realize such a turnout in Finland when comparing Vantaa and Munkkiniemi I visited. I was interested to know what have been the attractive forces for this massive turn out of youths in Mikael Agricola. Secondly, I chose the two congregations Mikael Agricola and Munkkiniemi in Helsinki because of the difference in their cultural backgrounds although under the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland. Mikael Agricola has a Finnish background while Munkkiniemi is bilingual (Swedish / Finnish) dominated by Swedish speaking population. I taught researching on these two congregations will give me an idea on 11 cultural impact on youth work. And Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe was chosen because it was the place where the first youth movement was established. Moreover, active youth work in Presbyterian Church has been my first the motivating factor for this comparative study. Thirdly, I choose the Finnish Evangelical Church because it is a state Church while the Presbyterian Church is an independent congregation. Thus comparing and contrasting both policies in relation to youth work will be of great importance. The research will be genuinely a comparative study with a strong empirical focus on interviews from youths, youth coordinators ,pastor and other church officials linked to youth work and my research questions are; 1. What factors influence youths’ attitudes towards the church? 2. Does church policy have an impact on youth work? 3. How active are youths in these three congregations; Mikael Agricola, Munkkiniemi and Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe. These research questions will enable me understand facts about policies, youths’ attitudes and their participation in the church and since it is a comparative study, it might help ameliorate youths participation in the future to an extent and will enable policy makers to have a different picture for the decision making process in youth policies. A hypothesis of the study is 1“Spirituality is the primary goal for youth participation in the church while socialization is secondary for youth work in Christian youth fellowship (CYF) in Presbyterian Church in Cameroon while socialization is the primary reason and spirituality secondary in youth’s participation in Mikael Agricola and Munkkiniemi 1 Spirituality in the context of this study entails Christian devotion to bible study and their belief in God almighty. 12 congregations in Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland”. This will be answered at the end of the research findings. Age is an important factor linked to human behavior. Since the research is based on youth participation in the church we need to examine the age ranges in the different congregation to see if it has an impact on youth work. Other important issues will be confirmation training in the various communities, their similarities and differences in confirmation process and its significance to youths in those congregations. The challenges faced by the youths and recommendations and vision for future youth works are important findings for the study. 1.2 Research method This study is a qualitative research based on individual and group interviews using a tape recorded and hand written manuscripts. The interviews entail two phases; youth coordinators and pastors and the youths in all three congregations. Interviews in Cameroon took the form of tape recorder and hand written manuscripts which entails open and close ended interviews because I could not travel to Cameroon myself to gather data. In some instances, emails and phone calls have been involved in order to collect data. In Cameroon the pastor of Down Beach Limbe was interviewed, the national youth secretary, two members of 2CYF Down Beach Limbe. Four members of CYF Down Beach Limbe under took hand written manuscripts based on the same templates as per the interview aided by a tape recorder. In Finland, interviews have taken two dimensions, individual and group interviews because of language barrier which has been one of my challenges in the course of my research. I decided to carry out group interviews with the youth coordinator of Agricola congregation and the youths in the two congregations in Finland. All interviews 2 Christian youth fellowship (C.Y.F.) 13 conducted in Helsinki have been open ended with the use of an interview template and a tape recorder. The Evangelical Lutheran secretary of Helsinki diocese was interviewed, the youth coordinator and the two youth workers of Mikael Agricola in a group interview, six youths members of Agricola Church in a group interview and in Munkkiniemi congregation, the youth leader was interviewed, the youth representative of the church council who is also a member of the youths movement and two group interview in groups of two and three respectively. The interviews were transcript and results analyzed in other to come out with a comparative study. Do hope the results will help strengthen some congregations in taking a different scope in youth work. 14 2 .THEORETICAL FRAMEWORKS AND METHODOLOGY 2.1 Theoretical framework. The main theoretical concept is on cultural identity and the socio-psychological impact among adolescent which is my target group in Mikael Agricola, Munkkiniemi in Helsinki, Finland and Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe, Cameroon. It is a comparative study of youth participation in these congregations with three different cultural traits such as; Mikael Agricola with Finnish traits, Munkkiniemi with Swedish and Finnish back grounds and Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe with Cameroon cultural traits. These different cultural traits have influenced youth work spatially in these three congregations. Identity is a social factor which can be attributed to cultural traits individually or in a collective scale. Identity can only be constructed when social actors are internalised in individuals. A persons` behaviour is influence by self-attitude even though social actors attribute to an extent (Ellemers et al 1999:8).Social factors have influence youth participation in the church as seen in the three congregations because of cultural differences. Societies have a great impact on the identity of an individual which may results from cultural traits and can be traced from infancy from the environment a person grew up. David Bohn, in Human Nature as the product of Our Mental Model states that “Concepts of the self-operate in the individual and in the society as functional realities which play a key part in helping to fix the bounds of that very human nature of which they are supposed to be model” (Gergen 1991:4.) My spirituality can be traced from my home doctrine and community I grow up which has influence my whole life to an extent. I’m from a Christian background and started my Christian faith through my mothers’ inspiration by taking me to church which enables to develop interest and the love to do the things of God. All my friends came from that same Christian forum 15 which has influence my behaviour and my social network. Based on my personal experience in life, the environment has a great role in our life. Some traditional practises like the confirmation training for youths from fifteen years in the Evangelical Lutheran Church has influence their participation in the church. Tajfel and Turner conceptualized social identity as an aspect of a person’s self-concept based on group membership with associated values and emotional significant (Ellemers et al 1999: 8.) Social network was a significant attractive force for youth participation in the church, in Mikael Agricola and Munkkiniemi congregations where youths` motivation of coming to church was based on socialisation and relaxation not because of their faith in God. On the other hand, socialisation reasons which have been a push factors has also brought some youths in to spiritual encounter with God because in the course of their activities they have had opportunity to listen to some biblical teachings which has transformed their lives. In Presbyterian Church, youth’s participation is more of spiritual encounter and a faith builder even though economic reasons have also drawn the youths closer to God to an extent due to high unemployment rate causing more people to seek God for supernatural blessings for a better future since God is their last hope. In a nutshell, spiritual hope has been the first motive in all youth work in Christian youth fellowship (C.Y.F) in Presbyterian Church, Cameroon based on the youth work curriculum others are just secondary not a fact. According to Tajfel, three aspects of social identity can be outlined; the psychological analysis of the cognitive motivation needed for social identity, analysis of real world situation in an intergroup relation and hypothesis of interpersonal and intergroup actions in defining personal relationship and behaviours to explain how social interaction differs and explains social identity (Ellemers et al 1999: 11.) Individual are different and have different motivating factors for all their action undertaken even though some actions could be influenced by the society they live but the mental state of a person has a lot to play in his or her actions. According to Gergen the process of social saturation in profound change in our ways of understanding of self in the cultural life in the twentieth century has been dominated by 16 two categories of the self. In the nineteenth century, we have inherited a romanticist view of self, one that attributes to each person characteristic of personal depth: passion, soul, creativity and moral fibre essential in the formation of deeply committed relationship, dedicated friendship and life purposes .But the romantic vocabulary has been threatened by modernist world of the early twentieth century’s with self-residence not in the domain of depth but rather in our ability to reason in our belief, opinions and conscious intention . Social saturation furnishes us with a multiplicity of incoherent and unrelated languages of the self (Gergen 1991: 6) The society has a great impact on individual attitudes as seen in the way youth conceive the church through the media which has affected their participation in the church in these congregations. According to Erikson, the autobiographies of extraordinary individuals are a suggestive source of insight into the development of identity. His longitudinal studies of personality development of children and guidance work with mildly disturbed children, relate that adolescent process is complete only when the individual has subordinated his childhood identification to a new kind of identification achieved in absorbing sociability and in competitive apprenticeship with among his age mates. The individual is forced in to choices and decision enabling the final decision to be reached for a final self- identification. Societies offer as individuals requires a more or less sanction intermediate period between childhood, adulthood, institutional psycho social moratoria during which a lasting pattern of inner identity is complete (Erikson 1959:110-111.) All three congregations had a chain of childhood spiritual development from children and family work and clubs in Helsinki congregations to Sunday school and Young Presbyterians for the children in Cameroon which has influence their spiritual growth. The cultural aspects like the confirmation training for young adults in Finland has also influenced youth’s participation in the church because many who have attended the training camps have admired it and have been engaged into more devotion to leadership training. The confirmation training in Presbyterian Church has been a booster of faith because youth are engaged in to in depth study of the bible which has had a positive effect in their life. 17 2.2 Methodology The research methodology comprises Ragins comparative research method through case study as seen in these three different congregations and the qualitative research method by the use of interviews and hand written manuscripts. 2.2.1 Comparative method According to Ragin, the fundamental goal of social researchers is to identify order and regularity in the complexity of social life and try to make sense of it. This could be done through testing theories about social life contributing to a larger goal of identifying order in complexity (Ragin 1994:31.) Theories can therefore be tested by identifying concepts in different societies and comparing their outcomes. According to Ragin, comparative researchers examine patterns of similarities and differences involving a number of limited cases in order to familiarize the cases in the study. Thus, knowledge of the cases is an important goal in the study and when researching on diversity, by contrast, the category of phenomenon been investigated should be specific in the outset with the main goal of explaining the diversity in the cases investigated (Ragin 1994:105.) The main difference between comparative research and other qualitative research is the basic orientation towards case differences. A comparative researcher who focuses on diversity, on contrast by studying patterns of similarities and differences tries to examine diversity of the cases. 3This study is basically a comparative case study of three congregations; Mikael Agricola, Munkkiniemi and Presbyterian Church on youth participation in these congregations The diversity of youth work can only been analyzed when comparing the similarities and differences of the three congregations revealed after interviews were conducted. The comparative method used in the study is exploring diversity and 3 Details on comparative methodology in different societies could be seen in Oyen, Else (Ed). (1990). 18 interpreting culturally or historical significant phenomena in the three congregations. The first goal of my research is to identify the general pattern of youth participation and the relationship that exist in the three congregations. Policy of the church is an important instrument for youth work because differences in youth participation could be traced from the pattern of the implementation of the church policy towards youth work. Knowledge about the pattern of youth participation in these three congregations was gotten by interviewing youths, youth coordinators and some pastors through a design interview template. Knowledge about specific situation is important because every situation is unique and the best result could be seen when comparing other cases. The results of the interviews were analysed in order to get the similarities and differences in the structure, policies of the church, youth activities, attitudes towards the church and challenges in these three congregations. Making prediction is also one of the goals of social research according to Ragin, what motivated me to carry out this research was the hypothesis that youth work is for socialisation reason in European context because only old people are seen during Sunday service whereas, socialisation is secondary for youth work in Presbyterian Church. A theory can only be justify after been tested likewise a hypothesis could be justify only after been researched on. Knowledge of cultural and historical events is relevant in comparative research because events can be understood better through the interpretation of historical and cultural phenomenon. The confirmation training, training camps and manner of worship service has some cultural and historical values which has influenced youth participation in these congregations. Socialisation reason has also been the primary goal of youth work in the two congregations in the Evangelical Lutheran Church even though spiritual growth has a role to play whereas, the strong cultural affirmation of spiritual growth has been the main motive for Christian youth fellowship movements of the Presbyterian Church when analysing the culture and history of the people. 19 According to Ragin, exploring diversity is one of the major goals in social research which may seem similar to identifying general pattern and does comprehend in some respects; it is quite different when exploring diversity furthers an understanding and appreciation of socio-diversity (Ragin 1994:41.) One major issue was the policy of the church towards youth work in the three congregations. The Evangelical Lutheran Church has a youth policy and the implementation was one of the aspects which created the differences in the two congregations because the youth coordinators had different strategies in youth work whereas all the Christian youth fellowship groups of Presbyterian Church had a common policy designed by the youth’s department. Researchers therefore ignore general patterns and focus on diversities in order to outline the comparative aspect of the study. 2.2.2 Qualitative method After choosing the three congregations to base my research on, I developed an interview template based on the category of interest for my study. The interview had two phases, individual and group interviews due to language barrier and also hand written manuscripts from youth in Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe who were not interviewed. An analytical approach was used from the data gathered. Analyzing pattern of differences and similarities in the study can be seen in chapter six in the paper. The study entails a theoretical and empirical nature of research where by information where gotten from previous study and interviews conducted in the three congregations involved Mikael Agricola, Munkkiniemi, Finland and Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe, Cameroon. The interviews were tape recorded and manually transcribed. Interviews were conducted in two phases, youth leaders and coordinators, Helsinki diocese secretary, pastors and youths in the various congregations. The reason behind this random interview sample was to get an overall picture of the whole situations from leaders and youth perspective in order to get the similarities and differences and ameliorate the situation in the future. 20 Interviews were based on individual and group interviews. Basically group interviews were conducted in Mikael Agricola involving the youth coordinator and the two assistant youth leaders, and six youths. In Munkkiniemi congregation, the youth coordinator was interviewed individually, a youth who is a representative in church council (Ruuti) and two group interviews involving two and three youths respectively making a total of six youths involved. The language of communication was English in both congregations. I resorted to group interviews because of language barrier since the interviewees’ couldn’t understand English well since Finnish is their official language. In order to get overview knowledge of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Finland since two congregations were involved, I decided to interview the secretary of Helsinki diocese. In Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe, interviews were basically individually. The nature of the interview conducted took two phases; tape recorder and hand written manuscript from the same designed interview template .The interviews were basically open and close ended interviews. The interview at Down Beach Limbe was conducted by my sister who has been a member of C.Y.F but the templates were designed by me since I could not go to Cameroon to collect data. A common interview template was used in the three congregations. The interview conducted by the use of a tape recorder was sent to me. Those interviewed include; the pastor of Presbyterian Church Down Beach Limbe, the national youth secretary, two group members and four members sent manual transcript following the interview template quest which were close ended. There were instances of phone calls and e-mails on areas which were not clear. Data collected from all the interviewees were transcript and results analysed. Below is the interview template used in the study? INTERVIEW TEMPLATE 1. How is the church structured? 2. Does the church have a policy towards youth work? 3. Does this policy influence youth participation in the church? 21 4. Which are some of the activities in which youths are involved in the church? 5. What factors influence youth’s participation in the church? 6. Which challenges are faced by the youths? 7. Do the media influence youth’s attitudes in the church? 8. Is there vision for youth work in the future? 9. Which recommendation do you have for future youth work? 22 3. THE STRUCTURE OF FINNISH EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH IN MIKAEL AGRICOLA AND MUNKKINIEMI CONGREGATIONS IN HELSINKI, FINLAND 3.1 The structure of Evangelical Lutheran Church The Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland is divided in to nine dioceses with 466 parishes and each parish is an independent working unit. 4The dioceses include, Turku, Tampere, Oulu, Mikkeli, Porvoo, Kuopio, Lapua, Helsinki and Espoo. Parishes in the same municipalities or cities belong to the same parish union and the same parish board. Each parish in the union has a parish council corresponding to the parish council of a single parish. The Evangelical Lutheran Church of Finland is a state church with public finances from taxes from their Christian members in the form of membership fee collected together with state communal tax (Kirkko Helsingissä) Locally elected parish officials determines tax rate to be collected from it members. The church also tax cooperation irrespective of whether their employees are church members which is justified through social services such as diaconia and maintenance of grave yards and church property (Antola et al 2006: 49.) Table 1 4 Markku Antola, Marketta,& et el (p, 49-50) gives details explanation of church administration 23 THE STRUCTURE OF FINNISH EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN CHURCH (Kirkko Helsingissä) The general synod is the highest authority in decision making of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Finland. It deals with the church work, doctrine, administration, Bishop Conference Church Council Council for international relation Commission for Church employees Dioceses Bishop Diocesan chapter Deaneries Diocesan Board Parish election Parish Board Parish Council Diocese Parish General Synod 24 legislation and financial matters of the church. The permanent members of the general synod include, the Bishops, the chaplain generals, 32 clergy representatives, 64 elected lay representatives of the diocese, state representatives, and a Sami representative elected by the Sami parliament. The general synod chair person is the archbishop. The general synod has a weeklong session twice a year (Kirkko Helsingissä.) The general synod is responsible for the approval of a new bible translation, Christian doctrine, hymnals, church hand books, mass composition, approves church order, order of church election. The general synod also makes statement and proposals to the Council of State in issues relating to the church and the state and with other denominations in important issues such as marriage and family, human right, employment, social security, church taxation, public education, religious instruction and so on. The general synod decides on the relationship of the church with other churches and religious groups and a federation of churches. It also decides on the establishment of new dioceses. The general synod nominates and dismisses the archbishop, bishops, heads of church council units, and elected member of the church council. It also confirms the budget proposal of the central church fund and decides how much parishes must pay annually (Kirkko Helsingissä) In the Finnish Evangelical Church, the bishop leads the administration of each diocese and oversees parishes and clergy. In 1817, after Finland was separated from Sweden, Turku, the oldest diocese, became an archdiocese. Since 1998, Turku has had two bishops the archbishop and another bishop. The archbishop acts as the chairperson of several national church bodies including the general synod, the church council, the bishop conference and international relations. Ten bishops hold power in the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Finland. A bishop is responsible to ordain pastors (Kirkko Helsingissä.) The church council is responsible for administration, finance and church activities. The archbishop is the chairperson in the church council other members include two bishops 25 elected four years by the bishops´ conference, two pastors, and eight lay people whom the synod has chosen for the same period of time. The church council has the following departments, secretary, administration department, department for church personnel’s, financial department, department for parish services, department for international relation, and separate units which include communication centre, the church research institute, activities in Swedish, office of bishop conference and office of the Bishop (Kirkko Helsingissä .) The Evangelical Lutheran Church in Finland has a total of nine dioceses and Espoo is the newest diocese created in 2004 and Provo is typical of Swedish speaking churches. A diocese is made up of parishes with the same bishop. The dioceses are divided into deaneries which consist of parishes near each other. A bishop is the spiritual overseer of a diocese and chairman of a council who take care of the administration of the diocese. The diocese council board is called diocesan board. The diocesan board is made up of fourteen lay members representing the parishes in the diocese and seven lay clergy. The diocesan has decision making power and has the right to send proposers to the general synod (Kirkko Helsingissä). Local parishes in the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Finland are independent bodies with democratic administrative policy based on the individual in the parish. Every parish has a parish board which is the supreme decision making body elected every four years. The parish board approves annual budget proposal, determine church tax to be charged, create and eliminate parish offices when necessary. The parish board select the parish council which is the highest executive board responsible for execution of decision made by the parish board. The parish council elect majority of parish staffs and the diocesan board appoint pastors proposed by the parish council. Parishes within the same municipality or cities belong to the same parish board. (Kirkko Helsingissä.) 26 3.1.1 The policy of the Church Based on the interview with the secretary of Helsinki diocese, the Finnish Evangelical Lutheran Church has some common strategies and programme for youth work. The diocese has their own strategically ways and the parishes have their own plan and policies. Different policies are made on different levels. There are quite a number of factors which influence these policies such as sociological, ideological and theological in the past years because Finland has undergone very strong cultural changes in the past ten to twenty years and the postmodern era has changed the way of thinking and common life and people have turned to be individualistic as compared to those in the past. People are more independent to choose their own ideas, ways of life and also create their own religious thinking because they pick up species from different kind of ideological sources and put them together to create their individualistic way of life. This has been a big challenge for the church because the church has always represented a certain kind of universal values and have not emphasised on individual values. The value of change has influence youth work to an extent because it is difficult to find a more common factor and common experience and symbol which could gather all kind of people. The church is trying to create a new kind of symbol to move forward and the confirmation training is a long traditional Christian value in the Evangelical Lutheran Church which is still strong today. About 90% of youths participate in confirmation training as compared to some other European countries such as Sweden with about 30% and United Kingdom with only 10%. It is still important for young people to appreciate the traditional prayer life and opportunity to share experiences of science which has dominated the media today because people represent different ideological views of life but the basic Christian rule is still important as youths are still participating in this traditional doctrine of confirmation training. The question we need to find out is if these policy influences youths attitude in the church? Based on the Helsinki diocese secretary view, the church have lots of different types of strategies plan, programmes, books and materials for youth work but parishes have their 27 own plans which are generally youth work visions and strategies. In the past ten years, the main theme developed for young starting from ten to fourteen years has been “God exists” life is now and holy and lovely God. Based on the interview with Munkkiniemi youth coordinator, most youths attend the confirmation training and leadership training but since most youths leave their cities for studies and other works of life, there is no strong bond for continuity of youth work and youths find themselves missing in the church except in situations that they get engaged in the city council youth work or university youth club if not they are seen back in the church only after having children in the children and family work.. Before Finland got its independence, the church took responsibility for the national educational system of Christian customs among Finns and instituted the confirmation training in which the church act stipulated that in order to get married it was necessary to undertake Holy Communion which could only be given after confirmation training and confirmation. After Finland got its independence from Russia and as a result of the freedom of religion, the Evangelical Lutheran Church has independently regulated its administrative policy, allowing confirmation as a precondition for church wedding, burial and being a god parent (Innanen, Niemelä and Porkka 2010: 140.) This policy has influence youth participation in the church because most people want to be married, be God parent and be buried in the church. 3.1.2 The confirmation training 5Confirmation is the affirmation of faith after concluding confirmation classes, in which the confirmed has the right to participate independently in the Holy Communion. Rippikoululeiri in Finnish is literally translated as the confession school camp in the confirmation classes, basics of Christian faith and community in to which one was 5 Markku Antola, Marketta & et el in “To be a Christian in Finland” (2006) also affirms confirmation class relevant for all Finnish youths from fifteen years in page 6. 28 baptized as a baby are taught and in Finland the age for confirmation classes is fifteen years. During the confirmation training period, youth are obliged to attend church service; assist in church service in a recorded number of times. The confirmation classes is a big institution in the Evangelical Lutheran Church and every year about 2000 young people participate in confirmation group and leadership training which is the biggest voluntary work. People seldom speak of confirmation in the public in Finland. One can participate in Holy Communion only after attending the confirmation training which is considered as the first confession of sins and been confirmed actually (Innanen, Niemelä and Porkka 2010:139-142). Confirmation training in Finland is partly youth culture where young people are happy to participate in for the eligibility for marriage, been a god parent, burial and socialisation reasons. The freedom of religion act accepted in Finland in 2003 changed the status of religious education in schools where pupil had the right to receive the teachings of their own religion with curriculum slightly different from the other but the 13 accepted curricula are based on the need of the civil society. A survey conducted in 2004 involving church employees reveals that confirmation work , baptism and funerals are the most important field of work in the church ((Innanen, Niemelä and Porkka 2010:144.) One relevant question to be answered is; what happens after confirmation which is relevant for my research. After confirmation, those interested in parish activity work as volunteers in church youth work and the main duties of these volunteers is to work as assistance leaders in upcoming confirmation camps or in children and youth work units. Youths are empowered through this voluntary work. In every confirmation training, about a third or fourth participants engages in this group leadership course. It is an essential part of the church and is a church culture in Finland to serve as a group leader which is important but when they reach twenty years, it becomes difficult to cope with these activities because more often they have to move to different cities for studies and are force to leave their home parishes. 29 3.2 The structure of Mikael Agricola parish The Evangelical Lutheran Church in Finland has a hierarchical structure with the synod been the highest body, followed by the bishop, church council, diocese and parish council. Agricola Church hierarchical hierarchy begin at the parish council with Pastor Matti Poutianen being the parish council head (Kirkkoherra) with sixteen parish council members for a period of four years elected by the parish members from 2011-2014.The parish council elects the church employees and plan parish finance and meet once a month. Mikael Agricola Church has a hierarchical or line organization structure with twelve managing team ( Johtoryhmä) made up of the chaplain, church music, diaconal work, child and family work, youth work, adult work by the priest, porters and other administrative offices like the secretary and so on. Mikael Agricola has a boss (Hallinto) who manages the affairs of the church in collaboration with the parish council and this department is in charge of customers’ services, finance and information or communication. Gods Service workers are 32 (Jumalan palveluselämä) and work hand in hand with the administrative board (Kirkko Helsingissä). 3.2.1 Role of Mikael Agricola parish Agricola parish as part of the Evangelical Lutheran Church offers baptism, wedding ceremonies and funerals. Other activities include, music clubs for toddler from 0-6 years of age , Child and family work (Lapsi ja Perhetyö) which involved day clubs for children aged 3-6 years, developmental and creative culture, songs, play and craft work on Mondays, Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Friday from 09-1200 at 100euro cost. The youth work department (Nuorisotyö) is in charge of youth work. This department has different groups such as children between 6-14 years ( Varhais-nuorisotyö) or school age children who participate in cost free clubs, various excursions, patrol, and camp events, Fifteen years old youths (Rippikoulutyö) undertake confirmation classes and 30 Adult work with the priest Aikuistyö has different groups it operates with adult work and projects in small group (Aikuistyö pienryhmat ja projektit, mission work (Lähetystyö), friendship parish work (Ystävyysseurakuntatyö) and young adult (Nuoret aikuiset).Young adults participate in bazaars, café, gym, prayers, summer camps and participate in diaconal work taking charge of social work. The Music depart is made up of seven organists who are in charge of church music ( Johtava Kirkkomuusikko).And finally the church services department (Kirkonpalvelutyö) which include the porter services (Ylivahtimesteri) take charge of other services. (Kirkko Helsingissä). Mikael Agricola congregation takes charge of the youths activities even though it is runned by the priest and the youth coordinators. 3.2.2 Youths participation in Mikael Agricola Church Based on the youth’s interview, the age range of youths who attend the Wednesday service from 20:00-22:00 in Mikael Agricola Church is from 15-25 years. There is the present of music animating team composed of youths. Youths are mostly involved in the youths evening on Thursdays, confirmation camps, music evening, team leader training on Wednesday, football team on Fridays, children clubs (7-12), home groups which became operational on the 21 February 2012. Youths also mentioned in their interview that their activities are not unique, even though they follow some common programmes like confirmation training, Wednesday service, team leader training for those involves but some participate in other activities like football, music team, volunteering in arranging the alter, lead children clubs for children from seven – twelve year with a token of twenty Euros. Youth’s participation depends on the individual involvement. Some focus only on the Wednesday service and camp meetings while others are involved in music, technical events, football, and arranging the altar and taking care of children in club meetings. 31 Youth’s evenings involve playing table board games, drinking tea and coffee, socialisation place for students, bible study which last for half an hour and confirmation camp, Friday music evening is a little bit more for young adult. Based on the youth interview, some youths in Agricola takes care of children in the club meeting in which they are given a token of twenty Euros a month just to encourage them. Just the work experience the youths are getting out of these act is essential in their life and for the growth of the church especially now that the church is having a drop in paid personnel’s because most people are leaving the church. Based on the interview with the youth coordinators, the confirmation training at Agricola church actually lasts for one week study period and the camp takes place in spring. After the camp, the youths are obliged to participate in the activities of the church. A booklet with signatories is created where the youths needs to sign five time to confirm their service attendance and five possible youth’s evenings. This is quite different from other congregations like in his home based congregation where one has to collect those signatures before going to the confirmation camp. He thinks it is better this way because after the confirmation camp you know something already about things, and one is able to make friends and can go with the evenings. So it is a more natural way to get involved. The youth coordinator thinks their parish is a place where people come and meet people aspiring God and you know this is their spiritual home. When people come and do not understand this spiritual language which is so different, they are taught what is to be done and why it is done this way. 3.2.3 Church policy towards youth work at Mikael Agricola congregation. Agricola church does not have a policy towards youth work as a whole but does have expectations on spiritual guardians or teaching which encourages the youths to attend Sunday and Wednesday worship services. The coordinators plan events such as the 32 Wednesday service, confirmation training camps, leadership camps, Friday music evening and so on. Based on the interviews with the coordinator and youth leaders of Mikael Agricola Church, youths are encouraged to attend Wednesday services in order to empower their spiritual needs. Youths have different needs and different families also have different needs and the youths do not have the same needs as other parishes thus their policies are different. One special thing about Mikael Agricola congregation is that the Christians are not always from this area. Teenagers are mainly from this area but young adults are from other areas. The young adults come from this region since they are mostly students who study in this area since there are three schools. According to the coordinators, the nature of Wednesday service has attracted many youths in the past three years with an average of 230 youths as compared to maximum of 23 youths over the previous ten years. Youth participation has been influenced by several factors. The youth coordinator has been there for about thirteen years and the youths’ relations have participated in youth work and have given recommendations to their younger ones, the priest has Baptist most of them so the worker are familiar to the families and have develop trust. Based on the interview with the youths, Agricola Wednesday service is quite unique and youths are given a quiet moment during the service to share their worries with someone else usually some prayer leaders or pray quietly, which gives them a feeling they cannot get anywhere else. More visiting priests share the word of God, so preaching is not done by the youths themselves. Offerings are collected for humanitarian purposes for those in need abroad or in Finland and food stuffs are sometime given to students who are in need. Everyone is welcome to the Wednesday service and today people above thirty years are worshiping in the Wednesday service. The actual age range for youth’s activities is from fifteen to twenty five with the exception of Wednesday youth service with no age limit. 33 Nowadays people above twenty five years attend the worship service because everyone is free to serve God. 3.2.4 Factors influencing youth participation in Mikael Agricola Church. Based on youths’ interviews, the main factors which have influenced youths participation in Agricola has been friends .Agricola environment has a unique feeling one cannot get from else were. The leaders are open minded making the atmosphere welcoming and unique. The camp meeting attracts the youths also because they usually have wonderful time with their friends, relax and read the bible even though they go there for fun. They usually have about six camp meetings a year. The youths also acknowledged the fact that the modern nature of the Wednesday service in Agricola with good music has been the main push factor for the increasing number of youth removing the believe of the old traditional notion about church service. The youth appreciate the manner in which the coordinator welcomes everyone at the entrance and at the end of the service by a hand shake at the way out and coffee and tea offered to those who want. More immigrants worship in the Wednesday service with English flyers on the main issues handed to them and also projection as in the flyers for those who do not understand Finnish. The camps meetings are also influential forces. Based on the youth interview, they believe the society have a way they perceive people who go to church and think it is only about hallelujah but that not true. Many youths accepted the fact that the image people have concerning the church is quite different from what actually takes place. Some youths acknowledged that music was the main thing which took them to church but in the course worshiping in church in order to listen to music, they have been more inclined to God than the music they taught. Our desire is to spread the word so that more and more people have the opportunity to come to church and see for themselves. 34 Based on the interview with the coordinator, all religion is corrupted by the media and people turn to be individualistic. Helsinki sanomat is the biggest influence to the youths in relation to a negative attitude towards the church. Most people believe in the media and any simple happening can be so complex when analyse through a media. The media is mostly based on science. Agricola youths were not affected by the 6TV show on same sex marriages. Sexuality has never been an issue in Agricola. 3.2.5 Vision of youth work in Agricola Church The youth coordinators’ vision of youth work at Agricola Church is to get the youths involved in the bible and grow spiritually. The next question is how can this be achieved? With the increasing number of Wednesday service attendees without knowing their motives, the Agricola youth leaders thought it wise to have a session with the youth 14 February 2012 to enquire their motives for coming so that the area of their needs may be strengthen, but unfortunately the turnover was so poor but at least some needs were raised such as the formation of home group meetings and a youth offered a place for the first meeting to be held. The youths who were willing to begin the group opened a face book group page for information flow but that group has not been increasing in the number but there is still hope in the future because it took quite a long time for the Wednesday service to be what it is today. Youths at Agricola Church have a positive vision for the growth of the church, and see the environment as a place where everyone is welcome and since the workers are welcoming and interactive. 6 Details on the consequences of a TV show in the membership of Evangelical Lutheran Church Christians in Finland can be seen in Aalto, Anni 2010 article. 35 The Wednesday service has been a pull factor where youths have had an opportunity to socialise and hear the word of God at the same time the increasing turn out indicate and active social network 3.2.6 Challenges faced by youths in Mikael Agricola Church Based on youth interviews, the youth are faced with the challenge of having mixed feelings about the world and also with the problem of believing in God or science been taught in school. Youths also have the problem of sexuality because they are growing in a culture with values on sexuality and since they are growing up to become men and women they find it hard to find their own way of thinking and do not know how to base their mind since everything is open and there is no right or wrong. There is no good philosophy in the world and many people are so frustrated because of different concept of liberalism, conservatism and so on. 3.3 Recommendations for youth work in Agricola The youths recommended that the right image of the church should be portrayed in the community because many people have different views about the church and the old fashioned modality of service should be transformed like the Wednesday service which is so lively in other congregations. Most youths had a different view about the church and came to realise the difference only after worshiping in the youth service which has not been the way they taught. The community should be sensitised about the church because most people still belief the different school of taught from the media be it conservative or liberal ideas and do have the notion that the church is just a hallelujah thing which is boring. People should begin to focus on the word of God and read the bible to gain knowledge. One important thing about the youth service is that it gives a 36 different picture because the picture people have about service is sitting on a bench with old people and everything boring. One good thing in Agricola service is that the service and the religious life is focus more to the people’s life and culture such that we protect their tradition and care more about the evolving society. The youth coordinator, recommended more focus on spiritual growth and a way of explaining the spirit world to the youths because most of them do not understand when God is calling them so there should be greater spiritual touch on God’s calling because some youths have had such feeling in their heart and instead consulted the doctor in which they have been on pills medication which did not do any good to them but as most of them turn to follow the things of God they have realised that it was God calling them. It will be good for emphasis to be made on how the Holy Spirit administers to Christians. The coordinators intend to open bible reading group in 2012. 3.4 The structure of Munkkiniemi Church Munkkiniemi parish church was completed in 1954 and designed by architect Paul Salomaa. Based on the interview with the youth coordinator, Munkkiniemi is a parish in the Helsinki forming a coalition known as seurakunayhtymä and each local congregation has their own board called Seurakunta neuvosto. Member of Munkkiniemi elect their board after every five years. Board members make decisions on work, activities and projects in the congregation. Two members of Munkkiniemi are in the Seurakuntayhtymä board. Tax money goes to the main board (Seurakuntayhtyymä) in Helsinki and they make the final decision on basic of work in each congregation. Munkkiniemi local board members then decide on how to use the money. Munkkiniemi parish has the regular Sunday service which is mostly made up of old people and Wednesday youths meetings which is one of the main activities for the youths apart from the confirmation training classes. 37 Munkkiniemi congregation have children and family work, youth work which include confirmation training, diaconal work, mission abroad and international diaconal work. Children work can be seen in different groups, for example, children under school age 0-7, work with school age (7-18) and young adult 18-25 year still in the developmental process (Kirkko Helsingissä). Children from 3-5 have their day club where they meet two –three times a week and focus on child care the joy of a childhood and spiritual nurturing of a child which enables the child to develop church experiences (Kirkko Helsingissä). Family clubs is a forum were parent and children meet in the same group which involves family devotional, singing and playing together in harmony. This forum also enables Christian educational support. Munkkiniemi organises club activities for school children in cooperation with the city of Helsinki education department. The diaconal area involves several ages especially working with old people but each age group has a team leader. The youth leaders were made up of the youth coordinator, two pastors and a musician team (Kirkko Helsingissä). Based on the interview with the youth coordinator, at the beginning of 2011, two congregations, Munkkiniemi and Munkkivuori merged together into one parish called Munkkiniemi. In Helsinki there have had six congregations joined in order to have a bigger and more effective congregation. But now Munkkiniemi have a little more people working as full time and have about twelve thousand members in this area who are going to church and this area is special when we compare it with other parts of Helsinki as they have the highest percent for those who belong to church. Munkkiniemi has a lot of wealthy people living in the area and very special in this congregation is that there are a lot of old people of over 30% of those who are above 65 and that is why there are few young people . 38 3.4.1 The role of Munkkiniemi in youth work The Munkkiniemi congregation has full authority over the youths because the youth leader is a full time worker of the Evangelical Lutheran church. The officiating team leaders comprise of the priest and youth coordinator. The congregation take charge of Baptism, confirmation, marriage, burial and other Christian rites entitle to membership. The youths have their actives coordinated by the youth leader but the youth are not solely part of the Sunday services. They can be assigned duties during their confirmation training period but are not oblige to participate or worship during the Sunday service. The youths are more inclined to their Wednesday group meetings, camps and part take in events that concerns them. 3.4.2 Youths participation in Munkkiniemi Church The age range is from fifteen to nineteen years. Based on interview of the youth coordinator, the youths participate in their weekly meetings on Wednesdays as from 18- 21.00.The first one hour thirty minutes is always officiated by a planned programme. They follow weekly themes from two books published by Nuorten keskus. One of the books covers the church year from advent to the last Sunday of the year but the person responsible for the meeting decide whether to follow it or not. The other book does not follow the church year calendar but is more variable and comprise nature, environment, and peace, sex and so on. The official programme comprises, a short bible story, and maybe singing and then goes to a small chapel which is more relaxing and sometime light prayer candles, listen to someone who may like to tell a story or do something, or listen to music and at times have a silence moment and take coffee, tea and snacks. 39 Based on youth interviews, youths in Munkkiniemi congregation sometime organises Wednesday special service in which the youths participate in most activities because they seldom attend Sunday service which they considered as service for old people. The youths also organise events on Saturdays involving music, bible reading, lecture and coffee even though it is not restricted only for youth but majority of attendees are youths. Some youths have had training in participating in Sunday service for example reading the lesson and also to help in the Holy Communion. There has to be a pastor to lead the Holy Communion, but the others serving there can be workers or volunteers. Based on youth’s interview, confirmation training is also important for youth work. Youths also participate in leadership training for confirmation camps. Overall participants for camp meetings are from forty to fifty and these camp meetings usually take place once in two months on weekends. Leadership training camps are common during summer. Some youths are so excited about the confirmation camp and they keep on attending camp meetings over and over again. Youths do not really have any task to accomplish in the parish itself but are free to go there whenever they want but it’s not obligatory. Bazaars are some time organised in which the youths participate in. Recently, a youth has been elected to work in the council board called Ruuti. This youth has been an active member in the Munkkiniemi parish for five years. Ruuti board members go to the city board and gives suggestions to those running the city. 3.4.3 Church policy towards youth work at Munkkiniemi congregation Based on the youth coordinators interviews, Munkkiniemi does not have any specific youth policy but do have administrative bureau known in Finnish as seurankunta neuvonto which take care of the whole church. The youths do have an annual plan for the local congregations with goals and actions for one or few years at local level. At the national level, the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Finland has several policy 40 documents; one is for work among children and youth. Participation was one of the focuses during this year (2011). There is also a theme for three years “The Holy”. This is the second year of the Holy as focus. During “The Holy” years we try to encourage people to attend Sunday services. The Church policy influences youth’s participation to an extent because youths activities are not suppose to be centrally to church norms. The youths in Agricola were not aware of any church policy and only spoke of rules which abide discipline. The youths also acknowledged the fact that only the youth movement at the city council have some policies which they are not verse with. 3.4.4 Vision of youth work in Munkkiniemi congregation Based on youth’s interviews, the vision for youth work in Munkkiniemi congregation is for continuity of youth work in the future. Some youths have decided to do an internship for nine months rather than going to the army which may enable them also get a job in the church which is quite positive. And there has been an increased in the number of attendees in youth camps from about fifteen in the past to approximately forty to fifty youth’s participants during summer. The average participants in camp meetings have been thirty to forty According to the youth coordinator, there is a positive vision for youth work in Munkkiniemi, because a youth have been elected in the council election which is positive, as she will be part of the decision making body which may present youths challenge for a way forward. 41 3.4.5 Factors influencing youth’s participation in Munkkiniemi congregation. Based on youth interviews, Socialization motives has been an influential factor attributing to youths participation in the church because they turn to meet the friends ,relax take coffee and sometime have a quiet moment. Friends have been a pull factor for youth’s participation in the Wednesday service. Other points of interest have been music for those interested in the music team while other just wants to have a quiet moment with their friends. The confirmation training is also culture that youths want to be part of it so that they can get married in the church, be god parents and can be buried by the church so about 90% of youths in Finland attend the confirmation training. The youths affirmed that the media has also influenced youth’s participation through the church magazine which gives them information about the church and some upcoming events. The internet through face book network has been an attractive forum where youths make new friend and see upcoming events and easy community among the youths and their leaders too. Camp meeting has been a motivating factor for youth work. Some youths enjoy camp meeting which instigates them to attend over and over and some youth have the opportunity to preach during camp meeting even though it is mostly done by the priest but the youths really have fun make new friends, relax and feel good. The youth leaders has been an influential factor for youths active participation in the church because some youth get recommendations from older attendees be it friends or relatives. On the other hand, there are factors which have influence the non-participation of youths based on the youth interviews conducted. Many youths are not interested in worshiping during Sunday service because the services are full of older people and there are no activities for the working population. Youths leave their home congregations to different cities for study and most find it hard to link up to other congregations. Some finally get engage in some university youth group while other just gets lost. 42 3.5 Recommendations for youth work in Munkkiniemi Based on the youth’s interview, the church should create a link from childhood to adult hood so that people can grow spiritually because there is that missing link of youth above nineteen years. Some youths are interested to continue but do not find a place because of age barrier and some find themselves in the church only when they have kids and bring them for children programme but they themselves do not have anything to engage to. Some youths above eighteen years still do have interest in continuity but they do not find their place in the group because of their age which made thinking of creating another group but the problem has been getting more youths of their age involved. The youths also recommended that more adverts and open events activities should be schedule during summer in an open area with music involve order to attract youths walking nearby. The youths also recommended that more time schedule for bible reading and music should be allocated during Wednesday meeting for those interested. Based on the interview with the coordinator, regarding the shortage of paid personnel’s in the church since many people are leaving the church today, youths should be trained to be able to run most events rather than leaving it in the hands of paid personnel’s. The shortage of church members can be explained after a Finnish broadcasting company televised a panel discussion on gender neutral marriages and the right to homosexuals in general in October 2010. Participants included parliamentarians, church officials and public gay. The church representative related negative religious views about homosexuality which resulted to a sudden influx of approximately 30.000 people resigning from the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Finland with an average number of about 1000 a week. This event has affected the church which depends on taxes from its members which has resulted to a drop in paid personnel’s in the church. On the other hand, in contrast of the resignation of members from the church, Päivi Räsänen comment about homosexuality from her religious point of view brought in 400 43 members in to the church and still in march 2010 a questionnaire was conducted among 200 parliamentarians about same sex rights with a 54 percent vote against and 46 percent for (Aalto, Anni 2010). 44 4. THE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH, CAMEROON The English Baptist Church came to West Africa in 1845 when the Germans took control over the territory. The conference of European missionary societies agreed that the Basel Mission should take over the work of the English Baptist Mission in 1886. Today’s Presbyterian Church is one of the Protestant Churches and a successor to the Basel Mission Church, established in 1886, and the church gained independence on November 13th, 1957 as Presbyterian Church in Cameroon (P.C.C). Presbyterian Church in Cameroon runs three general hospitals, rehabilitation centers, eighteen health centers, ophthalmological unit, a university, theological seminaries, secondary, primary and nursery institutions and centre for agriculture and employment training (Keller 1969:98) Presbyterian Church covers two areas, the forest and grass field area with Mungaka (Bali) and Douala respectively, English and French are also official languages used in church. Presbyterian Church is an autonomous body with the moderator as the main governing authority followed by the synod clerk, secretary, financial secretary and board members. The moderator is the spiritual and executive head of the Presbyterian Church in Cameroon. The moderator has a five year team of office renewable once. The Presbyterian Church has a triangular structure comprising of three main organs the congregations, the presbyteries and the synod (Keller 1969: 97) 45 Table 2. The structure of Presbyterian Church in Cameroon The local congregation is a spiritual assembly of believers in Jesus Christ. The believers come together to fellowship, dedicated for the teaching of the Holy Scripture. Membership of a local congregation consists of Christians who have affirmed their faith in baptism and submit to the discipline of the church. The local congregation can be Synod of P.C.C Departments CWF, CMF Institutions Regional Committees Presbytery Committees Zonal Committees Congregations Presbyteries Congregations NATCOM 46 recognized by written authorization of the moderator based on the decision of the synod committee (The constitution 1998: 12). The local congregation is the basic unit and at the same time expresses the universal church of Christ at its locality. The congregations are small parishes headed by a pastor, congregational chairman and the session which is a committee of elders elected by congregational members. Congregations have a quarterly meeting were issues about the congregation are discussed and may have several meetings as situation demands. Congregational meetings shall be convened by the chairman in consultation with the pastor in charge. The local congregation in a certain geographical locality forms a district and there are sixteen districts with over one thousand congregations. The constitution of the church defines three legislative bodies namely, the congregational meeting, the presbytery and the synod (Cons11 §21, §30§45) with constitutional powers to make decisions on their respective levels (Journey of faith 1982:123). The presbyteries are congregation in a geographical region. Each presbytery has a chairman, treasurer and secretary in charge of administrative issues of that presbytery. Presbyteries of church include, Bafut-Tuba, Mamfe, Akwaya, Kumba, Bui, Donga Matung, Bakossi, Batibo, Dikombe, East Mungo north, East Mungo south, Fako north, Fako South, Meme north /Meme south, Ndian, Mezam, Menchum-Boyo, Njika, Santa, and Ngie (Keller 1969: 97). The synod is the supreme governing body of the Presbyterian Church in Cameroon. The synod office is located in Buea, the head quarter of southwest province. The synod comprises of the office of the moderator who is elected, synod clerk (elected) financial secretary appointed official, 2 elders elected from each presbytery where one must be the chairperson of the presbytery and the other a woman, 2 youth representatives elected by the national committee for youth work, 2 C.M.F represented by the national committee of men work, 2 C.W.F representative elected by the national committee of women work, 1 health service representative elected by the health service board, 2 Presbyterian education authority (PEA) representative elected by the PEA, 1 representative from each missionary area appointed by the missionary council, 1 47 representative of rural development board elected by the board. Elected members of the synod shall have a five years team of office and shall be eligible for election once. And elected member shall not be represented by any person at synod meeting (The Constitution 1998:28). The administrative head of the synod is the synod clerk. The synod is an open assembly of representatives from the presbytery, church institution and departments. The synod is made up of representatives from all the districts from the church elected by the presbytery. The synod meets once a year but can hold extra ordinary meetings if needs arises as stated in the church constitution in §49.And its decisions are guided by the word of God and the constitution of the church. Thus the synod is concerned for the spiritual building of the whole church spreading the gospel within and beyond its region and offering services to the society through its institutions and various branches of work. The synod has an oversight of the whole church and deliberates on all matters concerning the doctrine, worship, discipline and organization in all legislation as stated in the constitution in § 51 and 52.The synod committee coordinates the work of all the committees and boards of the synod and proposes policy matters to the synod which takes decision on them and also report all activities to the synod for approval (Journey of faith 1982: 124).The synod committee meets quarterly and takes action on behalf of the synod and may meet in closed session when it deem it necessary. The Church has several departments such as women’s work department, health, education, communication department, and youth work department, department for men work, Presbyterian printing press, and Presbyterian bookshop and so on. One can say that youth work of the PCC dates as far back as the first congregation, as each congregation established a children’s service called Sunday school. This unorganized service continued without changes until the early 1950s when Mr Thomas N Amaze now Rev Amaze became travelling Sunday school uncle in the grass field area. The Basel Mission decided to train two part time pastors Rev Ayongwa and Rev Dosa Etic in Akwa to focus on Sunday school work. From this humble beginning evolved what is known today as Christian youth fellowship (CYF) and its younger 48 branch the young Presbyterians (YP). Sunday school work has been the basis of church grounds for youth work. Sunday school could no longer satisfy the spiritual needs of young Christian entering secondary schools. The challenges called for new methods of preaching the gospel to an ever increasing youthful population The Rev. Ulrich Bachmann, and then Pastor of Victoria (now Limbe) introduced a fellowship of Youths (FOY) in 1957 (Journey of faith 1982: 44-45). However, it was on 5th September 1959 in Mutengene, near Victoria that the Christian Youth Fellowship (CYF) was actually formed with the Rev Mose Fondo and Rev Albert Miaz with representatives from Victoria, Bota, Tiko, Mutengene, Ekona and Buea with the motto, `Towards a perfect man and the aim was to bring youths together who desire to serve their lord Jesus Christ. Rev Miaz became the first youth secretary in 1959 (Journey of faith 1982: 44-45.) With the setting apart of Rev Albert Miaz as full time secretary in 1965, youth work was encouraged and the Christian youth fellowship was inaugurated and groups were established in many congregations and in 1967 there were over 150 groups. By 1964 a constitution had accepted by the general synod and the movement had been registered with the federation ministry of national education, youth and culture and was a member of the national committee of youth, sports and popular education of Cameroon. The Christian youth fellowship gathered young people between 15 and 35 years. Groups met for regional rallies; local groups devoted for bible study, discussion, games, evangelical work and occasionally had social work (Keller 1969: 133.) 4.1 Presbyterian Church policy towards youth work The creation of the department of youth affairs and the national Sunday school office was geared towards youth work in the Church. The youth department is headed by the youth secretary with the head quarter in Kumba a town in south west province in Cameroon. These departments’ works hand in hand for the spiritual growth which can 49 be traced from childhood through a solid foundation from Sunday school, 7Young Presbyterians (Y.P) to Christian youth fellowship (CYF). Materials are produced in such a way as to match the changing society and the age of the child. Policies are made in order to match with the needs of the evolving society even though all needs cannot be satisfied. Today, emphasis are been laid to the youth department because they are the future leaders of tomorrow. All the units are linked to together in order to build a strong Christian faith from their study materials. Sunday school and Y.P teachers are usually present C.Y.F members or people who have been members of C.Y.F movement in the past. The activities of these groups are unique in all Presbyterian congregations in Cameroon. Sunday school and Y.P head office take charge of their yearly study materials which are in line with the norms of the church while the youth department focuses on the yearly youth splash (Christian youth fellowship study manual) which is used in all the CYF movements in Presbyterian Church in Cameroon. This youth splash contains biblical study material for the spiritual growth of Christian faith, social and health education, and economical knowledge for youth’s empowerment. Groups are assessed in their zonal, presbytery and national rally competitions and prices are awarded to groups who performed well. The selected groups in different zones are allowed to participate in presbytery rallies and best performances are selected for national rally competition. This has been a motivating factor for groups to cover their yearly materials because these rallies comprise bible quiz, singing competition, exhibition of craft work and sport. Bible quiz carries a greater percentage of the overall grading in the competition. Based on the youth’s interview, the recent decision of electing a youth as an elder in every congregation has been a positive aspect of church policy towards youth work because youths voices are been heard in session meetings. Every congregation have 7 C.Y.F refers to Christian youth’s fellowship, Y.P refers to young Presbyterians and SUS refers to Sunday school. 50 meetings and the resolutions from those meeting are presented in quarterly congregational meetings which are sent to the synod office for final decision for the growth of the church. Based on the youth’s interview, the decision taken by the Synod to limit the CYF membership participation to twenty-five years has been greatly criticised by members who are still interested in youth work. The initial idea has been for those above twenty five to join the Christian men fellowship (C.M.F) which is under the men’s department whose activities are similar to the CYF movement but in a more matured way. Some member above the stipulated age are not interested in leaving youth movement and the overall turn out has dropped due to that decision. 4.1.1. Confirmation training Confirmation training and baptism are not prerequisite for admission in to C.Y.F movement. Presbyterian Church encourages infant and adult baptism. Infant baptism takes place when a child is baptised at infancy while adult baptism is a combination of baptism and confirmation rite done at the time after a person must have undertake a doctrine class of three to six months based on basic teaching of the church. Some people have been members of CYF before been confirmed. Those who under took infant baptism must attend those doctrine classes before they are confirmed. The confirmation ceremony is usually a big celebration where Christian takes an oath to serve God in front of the entire congregation usually on Sunday service. It is only after these rites are performed that Christians have the right to participate in the lord’s super otherwise known as Holy Communion. There is no specific age range for confirmation training. Christians are welcome if they see it necessary to follow Christian doctrine by accepting Jesus as the lord and saviour through baptism rites. 51 4.2 The Christian Youth Fellowship (C.Y.F) of Presbyterian Church The aim of the movement is to bring together young men and women who want to serve Jesus Christ as their only lord and saviour and to develop among its members a sense of responsibility towards the church and her mission in the world. This is the promise of C.Y.F till date (Book of order 1995: 67). Membership of C.Y.F is open to youths who have been baptized with water in the name of God the father, the son and Holy Spirit and to those who are willing to be led to Jesus Christ through the ministry of the group and the church (Book of order 1995:67.) Members of CYF on admission promise to seek under the leadership of Christ and in fellowship with one another, the will of God for themselves, for the church and for the world and to do it. It was therefore to bring youths together, who desire to serve their lord Jesus Christ, the development among its members a sense of responsibility towards the church and her mission to the world. At admission service in church where they are been handed their membership card which gives them the right to wear the uniform and the badge and they are called upon to put their faith in to practice. Admission of new members takes place after they have attended group meetings regularly for six months and their motto is “Live in fellowship with Christ” (Book of order 1995: 67.) The object of the Presbyterian youth department is to direct youths towards Christ, to bring together youths of the church towards Christ, to promote self reliance among youths and to carry the work of God to hinder land where the gospel has reached. All member of the C.Y.F are entitled to wear a uniform during official ceremonies which involves their participation. Members are handed their membership badge and card after probation of six months in which they are officially dedicated in front of the 52 whole congregation by taking an oat through their promise and their aim which is a symbol of acceptance. The girls are supposed to wear a white blouse, black skirt, black shoe, a red cap with the C.Y.F logo on it and a badge while the boys wear a white long sleeve shirt, black trouser, black shoes, black tie, a blue cap with the C.Y.F logo on it and a badge. C.Y.F is today one of the three basic organs or departments of the Presbyterian Church in Cameroon. The other two movements are the Christian Women Fellowship (C.W.F), and Christian men fellowship (C.M.F). The youths were the first to be established as an organized structure in 1959. The Youth Department in the Presbyterian Church in Cameroon now consists of C.Y.F, Young Presbyterians, and of course Sunday School (SUS).These three units are present in all the congregations. As stated earlier in the structure of Presbyterian Church in Cameroon, C.Y.F is structured almost same as the main church with groups at the level of the local congregation. Group operate at the level of the congregation. C.Y.F group can be approved after members have shown a sense of devotion to follow Christ and have accepted the rules and regulation of C.Y.F movement. The group will be dedicated in the present of the whole congregation and member will also take an oat in the present of presbytery officials. On the decision of the presbytery, a number of nearby groups may form a zone. C.Y.F groups have joint zonal activities which include; social evening or come together, joint evangelisation trips, revival visit for weaker groups, joint workshop and so on. Groups have their zonal rallies annually and the first, second and third groups that excels compete for presbytery rallies. A presbytery comprises of groups in a given geographical region. Groups within the presbytery have a committee which takes charge of the plannification of C.Y.F joint 53 activities like rallies ,courses, leadership training, workshops, camps delegate meetings and so on. Presbytery organizes annual rallies which comprises of the first, second and third groups selected during zonal rallies. The presbytery has its executive committee which runs the affairs of the presbytery which comprises of the presbytery president, presbytery secretary, presbyterial secretary, Young Presbyterian section leader, presbytery treasurer and publicity secretary.